Our history is grounded in providing practical insurance coverage with personal service.
Generations of local dedication.
All American Insurance has been located in downtown Meridian, Idaho, since 1973. The agency was originally founded by Jim Johnson, who later passed the torch to James Fullinwider in 1999. James expanded our footprint by forming the Idaho Insurance Agents Alliance in 2008 within the exact same building. Today, the agency is operated by his son, Peter Fullinwider, continuing a proud family tradition as a third-generation insurance professional.
Independent representation for your assets.
Remaining independent allows us to compete with multiple carriers on your behalf, selecting options that align with your lifestyle or business model. Today, we offer competitive insurance products ranging from traditional home and auto to specialty contractor and CPA firm policies. We focus on establishing lasting relationships built on transparency, knowledgeable assistance, and clear guidance during the claims process.
Our Mission
At All American Insurance, our mission is to provide accessible, dependable insurance options to families and businesses within our community. We leverage our independent status to deliver competitive coverage solutions while maintaining the attentive touch of a multigenerational family agency.
Meet Our Team
Insurance Designed for Your Needs
All American Insurance is located in Meridian, ID, and licensed in AZ, CA, CO, ID, OR, UT, WA.
Let’s Get Started
Request an Insurance Quote
"*" indicates required fields
Don’t like forms? Contact us at or email us.